ElectricMotorcycleForum.com
General Category => Pics and Vids => Topic started by: Richard230 on September 02, 2022, 08:51:15 PM
-
Here is a long video of a direct comparison between the LiveWire One and the Zero SR/F electric motorcycles by Yammie Noob. While I hate most of his reviews and his attitude, this review is one of his better ones, mostly because both bikes are ridden side-by-side and you can make your own judgement regarding his evaluation based upon what you see: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qMZIakSpidY
-
Do they convey false information just before minute 5 about what level 2 is?
Do they discuss the dealer/service network for the Livewire, I guess the one and future models.
Both manufacturers give these guys bikes to test out. Intresting.
-
Do they convey false information just before minute 5 about what level 2 is?
Do they discuss the dealer/service network for the Livewire, I guess the one and future models.
Both manufacturers give these guys bikes to test out. Intresting.
Yeah, he meant Level 3, which is the 2nd level of charging on the LW. It has no Level two, which IMAO, is ridiculous.
3KW on Level two isn't all that great but it can help to get to the next fast charger without having to wait twice as long as with the LW.
Of the three bikes mentioned near the end, I will take the Energica, of course. And MY Experia should be here this month.
-Don- Reno, NV
-
Well, you know the Noob, he doesn't always get his facts right. That wasn't the only mistake he made. Zero did not give him that SR/F to test. He got it from a local motorcycle shop that buys used bikes and loans them to him to review.
-
In term of looks, they should have compared an SRF (in black - i don't understand Zero's pastel color choice) with the limewire. Personnaly torque and 0-100 are important, so i don't why I would pay more for a slower limewire... But people can have different preferences.
Here is a long video of a direct comparison between the LiveWire One and the Zero SR/F electric motorcycles by Yammie Noob. While I hate most of his reviews and his attitude, this review is one of his better ones, mostly because both bikes are ridden side-by-side and you can make your own judgement regarding his evaluation based upon what you see: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qMZIakSpidY
-
I have to give it to the guy he knows how to work his marketing. When he puts out wrong info and people comment to correct him it drives up his YT algorithm. I mean if I had a $ for every review where they act like you can get both a charge tank and a power tank at the same time on a Zero I'd be a very rich man.
It's hard to tell if rider weight effected it that much or if the known fact that Zeros start to drop your power at lower SOC while the Livewire keeps it up until it's mostly dead.
-
I have to give it to the guy he knows how to work his marketing. When he puts out wrong info and people comment to correct him it drives up his YT algorithm. I mean if I had a $ for every review where they act like you can get both a charge tank and a power tank at the same time on a Zero I'd be a very rich man.
It's hard to tell if rider weight effected it that much or if the known fact that Zeros start to drop your power at lower SOC while the Livewire keeps it up until it's mostly dead.
I noticed that too. He mentioned that Zero offered another $6K worth of options and implied that is what you would have to pay to get the same features as the LW. Plus, he claimed that the Zero had its extra battery capacity unlocked to get it over 17+ kWh. That seems unlikely to me. I thought the Cyber Store was still not up and running yet. I am sure if you looked around you could find some other inaccuracies in the review. They mentioned that they are big on H-D bikes. Since the LW was offered to them for free to review they likely gave it some slack in the comparison. Plus, I don't recall any mention that the bike is now called a LiveWire One. One other thing that wasn't mentioned was how few LW1 dealers there are in the U.S. I went looking for a LiveWire dealer near me and all I could find is one dealer in CA, located in Southern California, about 400 miles away from where I live. Not very convenient, especially if you need service and parts. :(
-
One other thing that wasn't mentioned was how few LW1 dealers there are in the U.S. I went looking for a LiveWire dealer near me and all I could find is one dealer in CA, located in Southern California, about 400 miles away from where I live. Not very convenient, especially if you need service and parts. :(
It's says there is a LiveWire 1 dealer at:
1000 Arden Way,
Sacramento, CA 95815
But I see that is also a Harley dealer. Do some Harley dealers sell the LW1?
I see here also San Franciso as well as San Jose. (https://www.livewire.com/locations)
-Don- Reno, NV
-
It is my understanding that H-D dealers no longer sell or service LiveWires. When I googled LiveWireOne dealers I didn't see a dealer in Sacramento, only the one in So. Ca. ???
-
It is my understanding that H-D dealers no longer sell or service LiveWires. When I googled LiveWireOne dealers I didn't see a dealer in Sacramento, only the one in So. Ca. ???
Show me the link you're using. The map I have above is from the LiveWireOne website.
-Don- Reno, NV
-
It is my understanding that H-D dealers no longer sell or service LiveWires. When I googled LiveWireOne dealers I didn't see a dealer in Sacramento, only the one in So. Ca. ???
Show me the link you're using. The map I have above is from the LiveWireOne website.
-Don- Reno, NV
I was using this website, but I don't know how to see the map. It says to use control + scroll, but I can't find a scroll button on my keyboard. ???
https://www.livewire.com/locations?utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=Electric_LiveWire_Brand_E&utm_term=livewire%20motorcycle&gclid=CjwKCAjw9suYBhBIEiwA7iMhNGkiPwXRVFfwDBgBf2_2ZAchgVhESbp0mHpCipuskgIz7pdvDKKeARoCWwsQAvD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds
-
"I was using this website, but I don't know how to see the map. It says to use control + scroll, but I can't find a scroll button on my keyboard. ??? "
I use the scroll on my mouse. works fine. And you will then see there is also a LW1 dealer in SF as well as in San Jose and Sacramento.
But nothing in the entire state of NV (which is fine with me).
-Don- Reno, NV
-
Thanks, I'll give that a try. I had no idea there was a liveWire dealer in SF. The local H-D dealer moved out of SF years ago and relocated to South San Francisco.
-
Thanks, I'll give that a try. I had no idea there was a liveWire dealer in SF. The local H-D dealer moved out of SF years ago and relocated to South San Francisco.
I sort of got the site to work and located the address of the LW dealer, but what a miserable website. Could they make it any more difficult to use? I am not familiar with any motorcycle shops at 3146 Mission St in SF and the website didn't even provide the name of the dealership. I will have to use Google Maps to locate it and to look at the street view to see what is going on there. I'll give that a try tomorrow.
Who designed that website? The Cybermen? ::)
-
I sort of got the site to work and located the address of the LW dealer, but what a miserable website. Could they make it any more difficult to use? I am not familiar with any motorcycle shops at 3146 Mission St in SF and the website didn't even provide the name of the dealership. I will have to use Google Maps to locate it and to look at the street view to see what is going on there. I'll give that a try tomorrow.
Who designed that website? The Cybermen? ::)
3146 Mission St in SF (https://www.sanfranciscohd.com/Dealer-Info/Contact-Us)
-Don- Reno, NV
-
I sort of got the site to work and located the address of the LW dealer, but what a miserable website. Could they make it any more difficult to use? I am not familiar with any motorcycle shops at 3146 Mission St in SF and the website didn't even provide the name of the dealership. I will have to use Google Maps to locate it and to look at the street view to see what is going on there. I'll give that a try tomorrow.
Who designed that website? The Cybermen? ::)
3146 Mission St in SF (https://www.sanfranciscohd.com/Dealer-Info/Contact-Us)
-Don- Reno, NV
Well, that is a shock for me. I was working for SSF when SF-HD moved to SSF and bought a really nice lot and building just north of SFO about 25 years ago. The city gave them $300K in fee discounts to relocate from SF because they wanted the sales tax revenue. SF-HD spent a lot of money fixing up the building that they moved into. I thought they were still there. I bet they sold their building and made a huge bunch of money as property in that area is now very expensive, especially a few years ago. A friend of mine owns several Harleys and he told me a few years ago that they were still there. But apparently things have changed. I will have to let him know of the new location. I didn't see the LiveWire One advertised for sale on their website. ???
-
But apparently things have changed. I will have to let him know of the new location. I didn't see the LiveWire One advertised for sale on their website. ???
Perhaps they do not stock it, but I assume it may be ordered from there.
-Don- Reno, NV
-
But apparently things have changed. I will have to let him know of the new location. I didn't see the LiveWire One advertised for sale on their website. ???
Perhaps they do not stock it, but I assume it may be ordered from there.
-Don- Reno, NV
I was thinking the same thing, although I thought H-D was trying to keep the LiveWire One business separated from the H-D dealers, who don't really seem into electric motorcycles. ??? If you buy it from an H-D dealership and need servicing or warranty work, would they have anyone on the staff that could assist you? It seems doubtful, especially in how they dealt with Buell owners that had problems in the past.
-
I was thinking the same thing, although I thought H-D was trying to keep the LiveWire One business separated from the H-D dealers, who don't really seem into electric motorcycles. ??? If you buy it from an H-D dealership and need servicing or warranty work, would they have anyone on the staff that could assist you? It seems doubtful, especially in how they dealt with Buell owners that had problems in the past.
I think even HD had the issue with the first HD LW. Many HD shops NEVER sold the LW. Carson City, NV and in Tucson, AZ and many other authorized HD dealers did NOT sell the original LW. it was not possible to buy the LW at those HD shops and many others and also neither place had a charge station. I doubt it could even be ordered from those HD shops, but I am not sure about that.
I have wondered if they didn't have anybody who was trained to work on them or if there were other reasons, such as not enough bikes to go around to all the many HD dealers.
Now that many HD dealers have CCS chargers, I would think at least those would be selling the LW1. At least if they have somebody in their service shop who has been trained to work on them.
Many still have a CCS station at Harley dealers, those are the HD dealers I would expect would sell the LW1.
That some HD shops sell brands others do not is nothing new. In fact, when I purchased my Energica in Mt. View, I was NOT able to even do the paperwork for the sale in their Livermore shop. The Livermore shop was NOT authorized to deal with the Energica until they took it over when the shop in Mtn View closed down.
So, IMO, it is no surprise that some HD shops will sell the LW1 but others will not.
-Don- Reno, NV
-
I have to give it to the guy he knows how to work his marketing. When he puts out wrong info and people comment to correct him it drives up his YT algorithm. I mean if I had a $ for every review where they act like you can get both a charge tank and a power tank at the same time on a Zero I'd be a very rich man.
It's hard to tell if rider weight effected it that much or if the known fact that Zeros start to drop your power at lower SOC while the Livewire keeps it up until it's mostly dead.
They swapped bikes and I noticed the Zero wasted the LW in every drag after a couple of seconds either way, so sort of the opposite of the headline. He truly is a clever marketing guy.
Cas :)
-
The Noob did another video comparing the range between the LiveWire and the Zero SR/F. Personally, I don't care for his presentation and I really don't like that they ride like "squids" during the trip. I don't think it was a very scientific comparison, especially as for some reason they could not charge the Zero more than an SOC of 93%, perhaps because its OBC is failing. Naturally, the LiveWire traveled farther than did the Zero, plus the comments seemed to me to be heavily biased toward the LiveWire at the end of the comparison. Anyway, here is a link to the video should you be interested in seeing how they compared the two bikes and hearing what the Noob has to say about the two electric motorcycles at the end of the clip: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJ7bBlSVVow
-
I am not watching it but is he a bicycle guy, look at the muscle groups above the knee.
How does someone decide which to get if they intend on getting a bike like this. The Zero is a lower rpm motor, direct drive and looks to be a tube chasis. The Livewire is a high rpm motor reduction gear and the chasis is cast aluminum which sort of looks like square tube. Would not the Zero gen 3 bike without the fairing be a better comparison? The Zero does have more suspention travel doesn't it?
-
I did watch the video and I strongly suspect that the Zero was suffering some good old magic charging. Would love to have seen followup of, "hey we pulled off the road at 5% and towed it back to the shop where it's suddenly reading 30%?"
-
The range comparison between the two bikes wasn't helped any by the LiveWire being fully charged and the Zero only being charged to 93% before they too off. Since the LW was provided by H-D and the Zero was sourced from (apparently) a non-Zero dealer, it likely was kind of tired and not in the best of condition compared with the LW, which probably was detailed before being provided to the Noob.
-
That SRS is a bike that Euro Cycles in LV have been trying to sell for a while. Bur Harley gave them the Livewire to test so that was going to be the winner no matter what. Just in the footage they show you see him goosing and letting off the throttle on the SRS while the other guy is steady. The Zero not charging to 100% is a situation I'm not even sure has been mentioned as part of the Magic Charging issue.
I think a real test would show them pretty much equal with the SRS areo fairings and the LW having a slightly bigger battery.