An update...
I'm expecting to take delivery of a shiny new Zero SR/F next week!
I tried another round of insurance quotes recently. Some, but not much improvement:
GoCompare via website (Cheapest 3 options: £805 Lexham, £2761 BikeSure, £2803 MCN)
MoneySupermarket via website (Identical results to GoCompare)
Confused via website (Identical results to GoCompare)
BeMoto via telephone (will not insure any bike this valuable for ANY commuting in London - theft is guaranteed in their eyes)
Lexham via website (£781, fully comp, must use disk lock or chain at all times)
The BeMoto position really annoyed me. In my opinion, electric bikes are perfect for commuting: regular repeated journey lengths; driving through congested cities without adding pollution; low speed stop/start city traffic is more efficient for electric vehicles compared to petrol. None of this matters because of theft risk. Not their fault, but their underwriters are too restrictive.
Then, my Zero dealer (aware of my insurance concerns) made contact with Lexham directly. I've since been in touch with them, and they have kindly gone out of their way to get these insurance prices down. I'm currently quoted
£654, and I'm happy to live with this.
So right now, the only reasonable insurance option on the market I have is Lexham. I've been quite impressed with their efforts and have heard from multiple sources that they're very keen to get into the electric motorcycle insurance business. Consider the following history of events, a 45% drop since my initial quote in May:
May 2019 £945 - Initial Lexham quote
Oct 2019 £781 - Second Lexham quote (5 months later)
Oct 2019 £742 - Third Lexham quote via referral from Zero dealer
Oct 2019 £654 - Revised Lexham quote, bearing in mind that I have a history with powerful bikes and a high NCD
So, it's worth pointing out to these insurance agents if you have a long biking history (9 yrs for me), especially if it involves high powered machines (1300cc for me), multiple bike ownership (and therefore multiple sets of NCDs).
I've been quite impressed at the lengths Lexham have gone to in order to get me an insurance quote I can live with! The agent handling the latest set of quotes (I believe Olivia), seemed well aware of biking in general (both petrol and electric), and that was rather refreshing compared to some conversations I've had!