I retrofitted my first two Zeros (2010 DS & 2012 DS) with HID headlamps, high beam only, low beam off. However. on the 2013 FX I put a low beam disable switch on the bike so I can turn off the stock headlamp completely when riding dirt.
It's true when riding at speed on the highways a lower wh consumption by the headlamp won't make much difference in mileage because the ride time isn't long. However, when a dirt ride takes several hours the difference can be considerable. The last dirt ride I did was four hours (moving average: 10 mph, distance 40 miles). My power consumption by the drive system was 80 Wh/mi (indicated on my iPod). The headlamp, assuming 35 watts, would have consumed 35 wh for 4 hr. That would have been 140 wh total consumed during the ride. At 80 Wh/mi, I gained 1 3/4 miles extra from the battery by having the headlamp on low beam but with the low beam disabled by my added switch. That 1 3/4 miles would have been important if I had needed it to get back home!
So you see it is all relative to the time ridden. Obviously if I had ridden farther and longer my gained mileage would have been even greater. I ride a lot of low speed dirt, so on those rides, turning off the headlamp is important to me. I didn't have the ambition to retrofit an HID headlamp to my latest Zero, as I had done before, since I do so little night riding.
Trikester