Another way to look at it is.
Replacing your bike.
A. Really is the right thing to do, so they can get the old one back and do a full review to find out exactly where root point of failure is.
B. Keeps YOU and everyone else you talk to happy, saying WOW what awesome customer service. It's essentialy free advertising.
C. That thing catches on fire, and it hits the national lamestream news. ENERGICA MOTORCYCLE CATCHES FIRE !!!!!
how damaging is that to their rep and future sales. Especially when there are so many mouth breathers in today's society who'd see a headline like that and never ever consider Energica ever again.
They did the right thing for the right reasons.
Also, yah it sucks when you have something brand new and it dies. Sometimes components just fail, Energica got it bad, you can't tell with electronics, it ran for a few hours then died. Infant mortality while crappy, does happen. I had a brand new XRF I paid almost 40k for die after about 30 minutes of use. Solid state thingamajig went bad on the HV side. Typically these things take a day or two to calibrate, so it was being used for a bit before being sent to me. Sometimes this stuff just happens. The important thing is that THEY SEE THIS TOO, and are not playing games, are saying, here, take a new bike, get back on the street, and we'll figure this out on our time w/o hindering you.
I wish Bruker would learn this lesson.
Aaron