I have tried sport and eco modes and still prefer my custom mode set to coasting with the throttle closed. I might add that I have read my entire manual several times just so I don't forget anything.
But for my type of riding, I do a lot of coasting and find that it is easier for me to just shut the throttle completely, instead of trying to hold it at a certain neutral position just above off.
I grew up riding two-stroke motorcycles and am used to not having the engine slow down the vehicle on over-run. In fact, my first car was a DKW Junior, which was powered by an 800cc three-cylinder engine and had a free-wheeling one-way clutch that disconnected from the drive train when you took your foot off of the accelerator.
The ultimate in "slipper" clutches.
One thing that I have noticed on my 2018 S is that there is very little difference between full-regen when in Sport or Eco mode when braking. But the regen effect is noticeably greater when set to 100% in the Custom mode.