ElectricMotorcycleForum.com

Makes And Models => Zero Motorcycles Forum | 2013+ => Topic started by: vchampain on July 18, 2014, 12:10:38 AM

Title: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: vchampain on July 18, 2014, 12:10:38 AM
Two months ago, the belt of my Zero 2013 S broke for no reason in the middle of the Champs Elysées - it only had 3000 km or so, only riding on the streets of Paris (not really a "tough" environnment). After some discussions, Zero accepted to supply the belt, but I had to pay to have the bike transported to the dealership and the dealer had to do the service free of charge.

Today, I had the same issue : with an almost new belt, after rolling on a small pothole the belt broke and I was left in the middle of the traffic without any possibility to keep a safe speed. There was a noise as if the suspension was too weak, and the tire touched the frame.

Did anyone have the same issue ? My feeling is that either the rear suspension is too weak (which causes the tire to touch the frame, which causes a violent brake and an excessive tension on the belt) or the tension on the belt has been tuned to tight (which makes it fragile and breaking in condition it shouldnt).

Any idea ?






Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: Doctorbass on July 18, 2014, 12:26:33 AM
This belt require an alignment with in 0.25 degree angle  diff  for the parallelism between the motor and the wheel sprocket. otherwise all the torque will only be on one sid eof the belt and not shared on all the width.

These Gates belt are really robust but as the manual say you have to be carefull with them! don't twist them etc... these are made with carbon fiber inside and these have very strong tensil strength but you have to take care of them in all other force than tensil!

Doc
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: vchampain on July 18, 2014, 04:54:37 AM
Thanks ! The belt has been set at the dealership so i suppose it has been done correctly. The unusual suspension noise twice happened just before the belt broke. And thise noise happens all the time on pothole or when rolling down from sidewalks...

V
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: Biff on July 18, 2014, 11:05:26 AM
The noise you heard may have been "ratcheting" which is when the belt skips over teeth. It sounds like a loud clunk/pop as there is a lot of force required to make it skip, and the noise resonates through the large rear sprocket.

Ratcheting can be caused by an improperly installed belt (usually too loose, some technicians think that it should be loose like a chain if they aren't familiar with the belt on the Zero, it should be quite tight).

By any chance when you hit the pot hole were you applying full throttle, or did the wheel leave the ground and spin up quickly before contacting the ground again?

-ryan
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: Le Z Turbo on July 18, 2014, 06:26:19 PM
Salut Vincent,

On my DS I'm having many problems and no more dealer in my area.
I had changed the tire and as I was putting back the rear wheel I was surprise to see that I had a huge difference in belt tension when I was turning the rear wheel with the bike on a stand. The tension all other a full wheel turn was going from 20kg to 50kg !!!

Right now I'm writting an website where I will explain all the defects, mods, DIY repairs and maintenance. But for my belt tension problem I had to unscrew the rear spocket, re-screw it 90° from the initial position and verify the distance wheel axis-spocket during all the tightening of the screw. Has I was progressively tightening the screw I had to rectify the position of the spocket with a mallet. Now my belt tension is almost constant
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: Le Z Turbo on July 18, 2014, 06:33:19 PM
And for the rear shock, mine was leaking oil from the rebound knob and so the bike was just a bouncing monkey on bumps..
Asked for a warranty replacement at the beginning of 2014, still waiting....
In the meantime I'm using a DNM shock, a little longer unfortunatly....
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: Le Z Turbo on July 18, 2014, 09:42:16 PM
You also have to check your rear wheel alignement with the left and right marking at the rear wheel axle nut. If not align the belt will either rub on the lip of the rear spoket (only one side has a lip) or either the opposite, the belt will not be entirely sitting on the spocket (photo)
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: vchampain on July 18, 2014, 11:28:15 PM
Thanks a lot ! I'll forward this to my dealer.

I was accelerating on the pothole. But I also have the same effect when rolling down the sidewalk to the street while accelerating. And the belt does not look having a too low tension, or sitting on the side of the spocket. It sounded more as if the rear shock was too soft and the wheel touched the frame or something like this.

Too bad you had so many issues. I know some dealers are having lots issues and spending lots of money on aftersale issues, most of them are small but the real problem is that solving them takes lots of time, with sometimes incredibly inapropriate answers - for example when my new belt broke they refused to replace it in the first place. My hypothesis based on what I was told is that the EU hub in the Netherlands is really mismanaged, and takes commercially & legally stupid decisions that harm the brand big way. Also, when talking to the Zero HQ they were everytime very quick to find a good solution.

I hope you'll be able to have your shock replaced !
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: vchampain on July 18, 2014, 11:33:10 PM
PS : What is the adress of your website ?
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: Le Z Turbo on July 19, 2014, 01:11:06 AM
Oh my website is not done yet. I have many photos of the different things I have done on the bike like the ones I put here, I'm thinking it will be great to regroup them.
I think your shop is ATS in Paris, I've been there to visit while I was a tourist in Paris. Very nice people.
Aaron from Zero US is trying to do something for me but I and my ex-zero dealer haven't heard from the NL or the French commercial at all.

On my DS even with the shock fully compress the rear will is not able to touch the frame. Don't know if it's the same with the S model

Lauremt
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: vchampain on July 19, 2014, 12:29:34 PM
I suggest you escalate to the US team - there is obviously something wrong with EU aftersales teams. Either they have too much on their plate and/or low incentive to deal with defects/problems in a correct way.

I finally got my XU back, and i'll bring it to Lyon end july/early august. Tell if you're around !

V
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: Le Z Turbo on July 19, 2014, 02:16:15 PM
Oh yeah, I remember now that you will put the XU in Lyon countryside, in the Beaujolais wine county isn't it ? It's just nearby my home.
I'm sending my phone in PM ! Oh, and you can speak french on the phone ! I'm using english here to be polite with all the forum members from so many different countries !

Laurent

Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: Le Z Turbo on July 19, 2014, 03:20:37 PM
I'm working on the website.... it's taking so much time !! it will be on http://zeromotorcycles.free.fr (http://zeromotorcycles.free.fr)
No comment on warranty issues on this website, just D.I.Y. works !!!
I already have http://tandems.free.fr (http://tandems.free.fr) and http://automower.free.fr (http://automower.free.fr) but I'm having trouble keeping them up to date. I still have a familly and social life !!!
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: Le Z Turbo on July 20, 2014, 07:04:31 PM
Another thing come to my mind Vincent: Haven't you had your motor spoket repaired because it was getting play on motor axis ? Maybe the shop didn't put back the front spocket right ?
Just an idea...
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: vchampain on July 20, 2014, 11:01:31 PM
Good point. I'll check !
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: Le Z Turbo on July 21, 2014, 12:48:42 AM
Or maybe the spoket has been damage during the repair, making for exemple a sharp edge somewhere ?
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: mcvl on November 14, 2017, 05:44:17 PM
Same problem like Z TURBO on ZERO DS 2014 (4000km).The rear  wheel was not centered (bearing not in axle?).Effect:vibration @ 15km/h and some noise with belt.
Problem solved with re-centring the rear sproket with wheel axle. Result no noise and no vibration.
thanks
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: togo on November 17, 2017, 03:41:12 AM
I broke two belts.

Seem to have stopped braking them.  I think moderating my throttle a bit when blasting up a pothole-laden street helps.  Getting air lets the rear wheel spin up a bit, and when it lands, there's a big differential reduction to the small motor sprocket, undue stress on the belt, which tears off a few teeth.  And once you have teeth missing, the rest of the belt soon goes as well.
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: Skidz on November 17, 2017, 06:07:26 PM
Same here, broke two in 6000km's. Stopped trying to jump speedbumps and going WOT over potholes, and the belt is still fine now after 10k km's.
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: Ethestral on November 17, 2017, 11:19:17 PM
I'll jump on the bandwagon.

Broke two, high torque and the suspension travel seems to give enough flex to either the belt or the rear subframe. lengthening the effective belt path and allowing the teeth to skip/belt to break.

It's more likely it's a belt dimension issue. The design accounted for ideal conditions with a certain rider in mind. On The 2017's they increased the belt width and I don't believe people are still having this problem.

In the beginning they didn't expect those of us that ride stupid (harsh treatment of the throttle). While I don't think I'm extreme buy any means my riding style is outside their parameters. We play with the line of capable and danger. It's foolish to whack the throttle on any large displacement bike, typically you lose the rear wheel and drop the bike instantly. Watch some of the zero test ride clips and you'll see this more than once.

The zeros come close to throwing the wheel, there's a limiter that keeps it from happening at stop or very low speeds. At relatively slow speed you've got access to all the torque and if foolish enough it's easy to overwhelm the machine.

While possible to retrofit an older zero with the adapted sprockets and wider belt it moves the weak point in the system. The belt, while expensive costs way less than a new motor because of a broken keyway on the output shaft.

Basically my fix has been have extra belts nearby, and do my best to modulate the throttle when crossing debris or any roadway imperfections. Like mountain biking but I get to keep my breath and rarely risk vomiting when I push it hard.

Since your still reading, I'll mention I still love my 2016 DS. It's got enough power to make me giggle but not so much that I wrap myself around fixed roadside objects.
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: togo on November 27, 2017, 03:09:46 AM
The trick is to be in neutral throttle by the time you get air.
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: MrDude_1 on November 28, 2017, 02:06:50 AM
The trick is to be in neutral throttle by the time you get air.

unless you're actually jumping in the air, then the trick is to use the wheel spinup and down to change the angle of the bike.
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: togo on November 28, 2017, 04:52:01 AM
Surely you are joking, surely there is not time for such short of a low-gravity environment.  What, are you jumping on the moon?
Title: Re: Repeated belt breakups : any suggestion on what the issue could be ?
Post by: MrDude_1 on November 28, 2017, 07:26:12 PM
Surely you are joking, surely there is not time for such short of a low-gravity environment.  What, are you jumping on the moon?

Surely you are not similar with high speed enduro, MX or supermoto then. I used to use the motor all the time to correct my landing with my CR.
I dont have an FX to jump... or I would.